Accountability for Killing: Moral Responsibility for by Neta C. Crawford

By Neta C. Crawford

The unintentional deaths of civilians in battle are too frequently pushed aside as unavoidable, inevitable, and unintentional. And regardless of the easiest efforts of the U.S. to prevent them, civilian casualties in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Pakistan were a customary function of the us' wars after 9-11. In Accountability for Killing, Neta C. Crawford makes a speciality of the reasons of those many episodes of foreseeable collateral harm and the ethical accountability for them. The dominant paradigm of criminal and ethical accountability in struggle at the present time stresses either purpose and person responsibility. planned killing of civilians is outlawed and overseas legislation blames person infantrymen and commanders for such killing. anyone soldier will be sentenced existence in criminal or dying for intentionally killing even a small variety of civilians, however the huge scale killing of dozens or maybe 1000s of civilians can be forgiven if it was once unintentional--"incidental"--to an army operation. The very legislation that protects noncombatants from planned killing may possibly permit many episodes of accidental killing. lower than overseas legislations, civilian killing might be forgiven if it used to be accidental and incidental to a militarily useful operation.

Given the character of up to date warfare, the place army organizations-training, and the alternative of guns, doctrine, and tactics-create the stipulations for systemic collateral harm, Crawford contends that putting ethical accountability for systemic collateral harm on participants is lost. She develops a brand new concept of organizational ethical organization and accountability, and exhibits how the united states army exercised ethical organization and ethical accountability to minimize the occurrence of collateral harm in America's most up-to-date wars. certainly, while the U.S. army and its allies observed that the notion of collateral harm killing was once inflicting it to lose help within the battle zones, it moved to a "population centric" doctrine, placing civilian defense on the middle of its technique.

Trenchant, unique, and varying throughout defense reports, overseas legislations, ethics, and diplomacy, Accountability for Killing will reshape our knowing of the ethics of up to date warfare.

Show description

Read Online or Download Accountability for Killing: Moral Responsibility for Collateral Damage in America's Post-9/11 Wars PDF

Best security books

NATO : Its Past, Present and Future

The formation of NATO represented a turning element within the background of either the us and the opposite Atlantic powers. For the 1st time in peacetime, the USA had engaged in an everlasting alliance linking it to Western Europe either in an army and in a political feel. NATO: A heritage tells the full tale of this ancient alliance, from its shaky beginnings via its triumphs and screw ups to its present new grouping of countries.

HazMat Data: For First Responce, Transportation, Storage, and Security

The HazMat info, 2d variation presents an in depth reference for emergency responders and those who delivery chemical substances. contemplating the occasions of September eleven, the booklet is principally orientated towards first responder and emergency administration team of workers. Additions to this new moment version comprise Spanish language synonyms for all entries, and an elevated total variety of synonyms.

Cyber Security and Privacy: Trust in the Digital World and Cyber Security and Privacy EU Forum 2013, Brussels, Belgium, April 2013, Revised Selected Papers

This booklet constitutes the completely refereed, chosen papers on Cyber protection and privateness ecu discussion board 2013, held in Belgium, in April 2013. The 14 revised complete papers provided have been conscientiously reviewed and chosen from a number of submissions. The papers are equipped in topical sections on cloud computing, defense and privateness administration, protection and privateness expertise, protection and privateness coverage.

Extra resources for Accountability for Killing: Moral Responsibility for Collateral Damage in America's Post-9/11 Wars

Sample text

S.  A10. S.  A10. 50 Ibid. html. S.  A1. 47 Int roduc ti on 15 results of its investigation public on 18 June 2009, revealing that four F/A-18F and a B-1B bomber were involved in the attack on Garani. The F/A-18Fs were used to drop flares, strafe the area with machine gun fire, and drop bombs. The first B-1B strike released three 500-pound bombs, set for an air burst. This strike destroyed a mosque and an adjacent building. A second B-1B strike released two 500-pound and two 2,000-pound bombs. ” The third B-1B strike, less than 30 minutes later dropped a single 2,000-pound bomb on a building where the “B-1B Commander and the ground force commander,” seeing “similarly sized adults moving rapidly in the dark .

Also see Gary Langer, “Frustration with War, Problems in Daily Life Send Afghans’ Support for US Efforts Tumbling,” 9 February 2009, http://abcnews. id=6787686&page=1. introduction 32 deaths do represent America’s best efforts, and if the United States cannot, indeed, take more care. Indeed, the US military knows that Americans and others increasingly care about avoiding civilian casualties. Public concern shaped the way some aspects of the Vietnam War was fought. In February 1968, shortly before the My Lai incident, commanders inside Vietnam showed they were very well aware of perceptions of US behavior.

Rules of engagement were modified, and algorithms, weapons, operations, and ethics training were improved to meet the requirement for civilian protection. Examples illustrate how, on the one hand, institutional beliefs and practices can sometimes set the stage for systemic collateral damage and excuse them. Other examples show how the military acted to reduce collateral damage. Throughout the wars, the US military has acted as an imperfect moral agent, and its gradual recognition of the problem of collateral damage, its initial ad hoc responses to the problem, and the gradual institutionalization of a program of civilian casualty mitigation illustrates a cycle of moral agency and a process of organizational learning.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.75 of 5 – based on 14 votes